The Spanking Controversy

by Vicki Lansky


To spank or not to spank - that's a question that plagues many parents today. Those who don't spank have a valid point. Hitting teaches hitting, and they don't want their kids to grow up thinking problems can be solved by using physical violence.

"Those of us who don't believe in spanking," said one parent I met recently, "spank less than those of us who do." I guess that describes me too. I do believe spanking can be appropriate for toddlers in dangerous situations, when you need to get their attention and make your point fast.

Some parents also spank for willful disobedience, or when a child is inflicting injury on another. The main thing, I think, is to be wary of when spanking is a vent for your own anger or impatience. Discipline of any sort should be a learning situation, not a vindictive one. If you think it's acceptable, you have another decision to make - should you use your hand or another implement? The hand, some say, is the only tool. It's quick and it's personal. Others say never use the hand, use something more neutral, such as a paddle or a wooden spoon.

Which approach is right? Well, I can't answer that, but I do know that this is one issue that parents have strong personal feelings about, one way or the other.

| TNPC Home | ParenTalk | Articles about Toddlers | Comments for TNPC |

Programmed and Hosted by ParentsPlace.com,
The Parenting Resource Center on the Web.
http://www.parentsplace.com/
Last modified: Oct 24, 1995